Sunday, May 15, 2005


Hal Jordan's worthiness to step right back in to his old role should not a foregone conclusion. His goodness and heroism is not axiomatic, not after all that he's done, possession or no possession. And Geoff Johns's decision to make Hal's return to virtue a matter of faith -- like transubstantiation, either you believe it or you don't and doubters aren't welcome -- is either poor storytelling or a conscious decision to exclude certain GL fans from the flock. Or both.

Ultimately my greatest problem with Rebirth is that demand of faith, without which the story is far less of a story. It was written by a Hal Jordan fan for Hal Jordan fans and the rest of the reading population is just ancillary because Restored-Hal is not given any useful character development to convince the doubters. Either you remember what Hal used to be like or you hope that Johns will elaborate on Hal's personality once the ongoing series begins because here, within these six issues, we get nothing but a cocky sense of humor and some old jokes. He simply is.

... this review is excerpted because it is featured over at Buzzscope. Click here to read the full review.

Starting this week, a few reviews per week will be appearing on Buzzscope. The Shrew is either selling out or moving up, depending on how you look at it. Buzzscope reviews will be excerpted (no registration is required to read the full versions there), but the rest of the reviews will be here, in full, as always. This week's Buzzscope pile: JSA #73, Fables #37, and Astonishing X-Men #10.


Blogger Guy LeCharles Gonzalez said...

Hmmm... I like this way of doing things, using a teaser from the review, instead of simply linking over to Buzzscope with a list of what I reviewed that week. Consider your style bitten!

Sun May 15, 03:23:00 PM EDT  

Post a Comment

<< Home